After a six-year legal battle, the fate of a $70,000 diamond solitaire engagement ring will be decided by Massachusetts’ highest court. The Supreme Judicial Court heard arguments this past Friday in a case that will finally provide clarity to the age-old question: Who gets to keep the diamond engagement ring if the wedding is called off?
The final ruling, which is expected within 130 days, will not only end the dispute between Bruce Johnson and Caroline Settino, who were briefly engaged in 2017, but also set an important legal precedent in Massachusetts.
Back in 2021, a Massachusetts Superior Court ruled that despite Johnson’s suspicions that his fiancée was having an affair, the allegations were unfounded and it was his fault that the wedding was called off. As a result, Settino was entitled to keep the ring. Johnson could have retained the ring if he could have convinced the court that the breakup was not his fault.
But, then a Massachusetts Appeals Court in 2023 turned the lower court’s decision on its head.
A panel ruled in Johnson’s favor, stating that he may have had solid reasons to call off the engagement even if couldn’t prove infidelity.
“Sometimes there simply is no fault to be had,” the court said.
The Appeals Court asked the Supreme Court to take the case and decide once and for all whether engagement rings should be returned after a breakup, no matter who is at fault.
In fact, a majority of states currently take the “no fault” approach. They consider engagement rings a “conditional” gift that should be returned by the recipient if the relationship fails to culminate in a marriage. Who is at fault is not considered.
In this view, according to Virginia-based law firm SmolenPlevy, the ring is given with the understanding that the couple will get married in the future and symbolizes a verbal contract. Ownership of the ring is not fully transferred until the wedding ceremony is completed.
The law firm added that a minority of states take the opposite view. They consider the ring an “unconditional gift,” so if either person breaks off the engagement, the recipient gets to keep the ring.
Ownership of the ring can be further complicated by whether the ring was given as a “gift” on a holiday or birthday, for example.
The Telegraph noted that in the UK, an engagement ring is considered to be an “absolute gift.” Unless there were conditions attached by the giver, the receiver of the ring is generally entitled to keep it. Still, UK cases can sometimes get muddied when the engagement ring is a family heirloom.
SmolenPlevy recommends that the best way to avoid costly, emotional and drawn-out litigation is to enter into a prenuptial or premarital agreement, which outlines clearly who will get the ring if the wedding never takes place. This agreement also can cover what happens to the ring if the couple gets married, but later divorces.
According to The Telegraph, the $70,000 ring at the center of the Massachusetts dispute is currently in the custody of a third party until a final verdict can be reached.
Credit: Image by BigStockPhoto.com.
Like our bagels?
Order some for home!
We are now offering preorders for Friday pick up here at the shop.
We’ve got our hand-rolled bagels by the 3’s, 6’s & 12’s — add on a 12oz tub of one of our cream cheese creations to recreate the full experience 🙌
And if you’re really feeling extra (which I always am, let’s be real), you can also grab a growler of your fav cold brew latte 😍
(team Vanilla Bean or team Fireside?!)
Copy and paste this link to order:
www.hotplate.com/brazosbagel/4a503700-b6d2-4a6c-b1f4-56f91564e5e7
Or find the link in our bio 🫶
Share the bagel love 🥯
What’s your favorite cream cheese: ... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
Celebrate your anniversary with a custom diamond design from Elliott's Jewelers! Create the perfect diamond to mark your special milestone.
Learn More:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/custom-design/
Prices start at $2500 and up. Call Elliott's Jewelers today at (936) 661-5363 or book an appointment online at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/book-an-appointment/
Browse online at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/shop/ ... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
Photos from CASA of Walker County's post ... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
Every moment in your love story is a precious gem, and at Elliott's Jewelers, we know that the 'wow' should be nothing less.
With every Happy Anniversary, a life celebration of being together, as you prepare to write the next chapter of your life, trust us to create a ring that encapsulates your magic.
With every shimmer and sparkle, we'll make sure your love story shines brilliantly. 💍
Book an appointment online www.elliottsjewelers.com/book-an-appointment/
Browse our shop online at www.elliottsjewelers.com/ ... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
Every moment in your love story is a precious gem, and at Elliott's Jewelers, we know that the 'wow' should be nothing less.
With every Happy Anniversary, a life celebration of being together, as you prepare to write the next chapter of your life, trust us to create a ring that encapsulates your magic. With every shimmer and sparkle, we'll make sure your love story shines brilliantly. 💍
Book an appointment online www.elliottsjewelers.com/book-an-appointment/
Browse our shop online at www.elliottsjewelers.com/ ... See MoreSee Less
Message Page
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
Every moment in your love story is a precious gem, and at Elliott's Jewelers, we know that the 'wow' should be nothing less.
With every Happy Anniversary, a life celebration of being together, as you prepare to write the next chapter of your life, trust us to create a ring that encapsulates your magic. With every shimmer and sparkle, we'll make sure your love story shines brilliantly. 💍
Book an appointment online www.elliottsjewelers.com/book-an-appointment/
Browse our shop online at www.elliottsjewelers.com/ ... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
🌟 A heartfelt thank you to our wonderful customers for trusting us with their precious pieces. We are happy to serve you! If you need quality work done, Elliott's Jewelers is here to help. 💍 ✨
Call Elliott's Jewelers today at (936) 661-5363 or book an appointment online at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/book-an-appointment/
Browse online at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/shop/ ... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
Every moment in your love story is a precious gem, and at Elliott's Jewelers, we know that the 'wow' should be nothing less.
With every Happy Anniversary, a life celebration of being together, as you prepare to write the next chapter of your life, trust us to create a ring that encapsulates your magic. With every shimmer and sparkle, we'll make sure your love story shines brilliantly. 💍
Book an appointment online www.elliottsjewelers.com/book-an-appointment/
Browse our shop online at www.elliottsjewelers.com/ ... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook
Two proud buyers from Christmas in July Bingo - CASA Art Auction this past July! Dr. Alisa White - President of Sam Houston State University and Elliott Herzlich of Elliott's Jewelers - Huntsville, TX have been generous supporters of all things CASA for quite some time. Their love for children AND for this community is truly unmatched! We are extremely grateful and appreciative of their support and so happy to see the beautiful artwork from our kiddos proudly hanging in their home! ... See MoreSee Less
5 CommentsComment on Facebook
Looking good, y’all! 😍❤️
Hello, lovely friends!
You two look lovely! And I really like the art on the wall.
View more comments
This is NOT just ANY diamond.... We have YOUR one-of-a-kind natural diamond.
Prepare to surprise the love of your life this holiday season with diamond jewelry that reflects your passion, love, and commitment. Come see our selection of stunning diamond jewelry that captures cherished moments.
A One-carat Natural Diamonds start at $2,500. and up (depending on the quality), plus the setting of your choice.
No Interest Layaway available.
Learn more at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com
Call Elliott's Jewelers today at (936) 661-5363 or book an appointment online at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/book-an-appointment/
Browse our shop online at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/ ... See MoreSee Less
4 CommentsComment on Facebook
Featured Diamonds - plus many more
Featured Diamonds - plus many more
Opals?
Revive your family’s legacy! 🔄 ✨
Transform a cherished heirloom into a stunning modern masterpiece. 💎
Learn More:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/custom-design/
Call Elliott's Jewelers today at (936) 661-5363 or book an appointment online at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/book-an-appointment/
Browse online at:
www.elliottsjewelers.com/shop/ ... See MoreSee Less
0 CommentsComment on Facebook